Brad Wardell's site for talking about the customization of Windows.
Stardock responds: Bring it on
Published on October 8, 2008 By Frogboy In WinCustomize News

Apple has been granted a patent for the MacOS dock.

Read the whole thing here.

Besides the general idea of a userbar with "a plurality of item representations" that consolidates features like "launching and managing running applications," the patent focuses particularly on the Dock's magnification feature that makes icons bigger as you sweep by them with a cursor.

Some may recall this article that points out that not only have docks been seen in operating systems for decades but that Stardock has been doing docks since 1994.

image

Look familiar?  Apple has every right to protect their inventions. But their innovation with regards to the Mac dock is extremely narrow.  Stardock doesn't patent its software as a rule for philosophical reasons. But the lack of a patent doesn't mean Stardock hasn't been heavily involved in creating prior art.

 


Comments (Page 2)
2 Pages1 2 
on Oct 08, 2008
You have to give it their legal team. Not that this is a shining example of the patent office. The patent system needs an overhaul and too get with the times...at least maybe they could catch up to last century? Enforcing a patent is significantly harder than getting it. Great for lawyers bad for everyone else. Part of me just sees this as another feather they will throw into their marketing cap. We invented, we invented that, we created clean air, blah blah blah.
on Oct 09, 2008

I'm not sure I buy into the idea that the concept of a dock can be patented.  I'm not immediately familiar with the requirements for patent but, I think something has to demonstrate a unique, new and original function to be patentable.  You can design and build a new and better mouse trap and possibly get a patent for it, but only for the unique, new and original aspect of it.  The concept of a mouse trap itself isn't patentable.

Even as to the enlargement aspect on mouseover portion of the Apple OSX Dock that may not be unique, new and original.  It should be interesting to see this play out.

on Oct 09, 2008
another case of apple claiming something as it's own with no regard for others, no wonder i despise the company, just let them try and take away my docks
on Oct 09, 2008
They didn't patent the dock. The feature they patented is the magnification feature.
To permit a greater number of items to reside in the userbar, a magnification function can be provided which magnifies items within the userbar when they are proximate the cursor associated with the graphical user interface.
on Oct 09, 2008
Pixeleo said:
Everybody grab OD+ and run, or that guy in the turtleneck will come and get you
I'm not scared of Jobs. I clicked on your link and he looks pale and skinny. I think I could take him. Ausvet said:
This is crazy, almost as crazy as McDonalds Inc tried to close down family run take-away in Scotland called McDonalds Burgers a few years ago.

Judge told McDonalds where to go though on the grounds of the family name was McDonald and they were more entitled to use of the name than a Kroc even if a surname could be patented and besides Scottish history much older and full of more precedent than US Corparate law and even US history.
That's a pretty funny story. Jafo said:
To permit a greater number of items to reside in the userbar, a magnification function can be provided which magnifies items within the userbar when they are proximate the cursor associated with the graphical user interface.

Ah, yes, there we go. The patent is for rollover magnification of the items in the dock.



Quite narrow, really....
Yes, but hasn't OD been doing that for a while too? Is OD 2.0 not going to include this feature?
on Oct 09, 2008

I understand that Stardock is against software patents...but at the same time, I'd think defensive patents (ones that you register simply to prevent others from claiming it as their own then suing you over it) would be good. No active prosecution of 'infringers,' just evidence in your defense.

on Oct 09, 2008

Good point Taepodong. There seems to be a whole new industry of simply patenting concepts/ideas. This seems to have been cultivated mostly by lawyers. The issue still remains the same for the little guys such as inventors and small business.

on Oct 09, 2008
I agree. It would be the prudent thing to do just like doing a will or getting the proper life insurance for your family is prudent. It's just insurance for your company and worth the expense of getting it. And since the concept of a patent itself is in the US Constitution, something venerable enough not to be dismissed automatically as bad or unsavory.
on Oct 09, 2008
The only way Apple and Jobs will get my ObjectDock+. is peel it from my cold dead computer!   
on Oct 09, 2008

Sometimes there will be 'products' that are just so commonplace or woven into a culture that no-one ever believes they warrant patent protection, etc.  as it's a 'given' that everyone knows who belongs to them...or who they belong to.

Perfect example was/is Ugg Boots.  Some Johnny-come-lately distributor of them in the US decided to file for the trademark...and got it.....even though it was a product 'name' that had freely existed in Australia for half a century.

At the end of the day it mattered diddly-squat as Australian Law laughed out the claim...so we [Oz] can still call an Ugg Boot an Ugg Boot...without paying triple the price for a third-rate copy imported from the US....

on Oct 10, 2008
I think the Apple patent covers work developed by Steve Jobs back in 1988 when he was developing NeXT OS. Apple brought NeXT OS around 1997 and acquired all their intellectual property, including their dock. So Steve Jobs actually invented "this type of Dock" before OD, it wasn't Apple then, but it is now.

It's all here in the History of the Dock WWW Link
on Oct 10, 2008

One of the many reasons i have never like Apple and anything to do with it, maybe its me, but compared to a lot of other companies they like to display their greed publicly, and claim they invented this or that, hey thats just me, about a year back i had to  borrow my nieces mac for the weekend, well it was the weekend from hell, i couldnt get the cd out of the drive or figure out how to do it either, come to find out it was some kind of defect on this model and was recalled or something, just my two cents, people chastise Bill Gates, but how many people give away BILLIONS of his money to help good causes, especially since he has teamed up with Warren Buffet, world needs more wealthy people like these two

on Oct 17, 2008

 

I think it is not going to happen anymore as even after Apple makes it patent, Internet Piracy is going to rule & make it worst and we will always got dock as we are enjoying nowadays.

 

 

2 Pages1 2